Costco New York Gas Prices
Find the cheapest Costco gas in New York— every fuel center ranked by today's price.
9 Costco fuel centers in 9 cities · 0 of 9 sell diesel
Costco operates 9 fuel centers in New York, spread across 9 cities. Across the state, regular gas averages $3.722 and premium runs about $0.81 higher at $4.528. The lowest-priced regular pump is at Costco Commack in Commack at $3.549, while Syracuse in Camillus sits about $0.39 higher. Across the state, regular pump prices have eased about $0.42 over the past month, from $4.143 a month ago. Premium has eased about $0.37 over the same period.
If your vehicle takes premium, the lowest in New York is Costco Commack in Commack at $4.399. Pump prices shift from one warehouse to the next with local taxes, fuel-blend rules, and transport costs, but Costco fuel is members-only and usually runs below nearby branded stations — which is what keeps these pumps busy.
30-day New York average price trend
Browse New York cities
All New York stations by price
| Station | Regular | Premium |
|---|---|---|
| Commack Commack | $3.549 | $4.399 |
| Holbrook Holbrook | $3.599 | $4.399 |
| Staten Island Staten Island | $3.599 | $4.399 |
| Oceanside Oceanside | $3.679 | $4.459 |
| Nanuet Nanuet | $3.739 | $4.499 |
| Rochester Rochester | $3.759 | $4.599 |
| Riverhead Riverhead | $3.779 | $4.499 |
| New Rochelle New Rochelle | $3.859 | $4.699 |
| Syracuse Camillus | $3.939 | $4.799 |
Frequently asked questions
Which Costco has the cheapest gas in New York?
As of the latest daily update, Costco Commack in Commack has the cheapest regular gas in New York at $3.549 USD per gallon. Pump prices change daily, so check the ranking on this page for the current order.
How much is Costco gas in New York right now?
Across the 9 Costco fuel centers in New York, regular averages $3.722 USD per gallon and premium $4.528. Those are averages of the latest pump prices — individual stations vary, so see the per-station table on this page.
Does Costco sell diesel in New York?
None of the 9 Costco fuel centers in New York currently report a diesel price. Diesel availability varies by warehouse — check individual station pages for the latest.
Is Costco gas in New York cheaper than average?
New York Costco regular averages $3.722, about $0.10 lower than the national U.S. Costco average of $3.823. Wherever you fill up, Costco fuel is usually priced below nearby branded stations.
Do you need a Costco membership to buy gas in New York?
Yes — Costco gas stations in New York are members-only. You scan a membership card or a Costco Shop Card at the pump before fueling; non-members can't buy fuel at Costco.
How do you pay for gas at Costco in New York?
Costco gas stations in New York take any Visa credit card, PIN debit, a Costco Shop Card, and Apple Pay or Google Pay linked to a Visa — but not Mastercard, Amex, Discover, or cash at the pump.
What time do Costco gas stations open in New York?
Hours vary by location, and the gas station usually opens earlier and closes later than the warehouse itself. For example, the gas station at Costco Commack runs 6AM – 10PM on weekdays. Check the individual station page for exact hours before a long drive.